Comparing Garage Floor Mats To Epoxy

by Gerald Peterson on December 12, 2009

After reading all about all of the different types of garage flooring, you’ve decided that you either want epoxy paint or a garage floor mat. Well, both garage floors have advantages and disadvantages, so let’s look at some of both. Hopefully, once we’re done, you will have a better grasp on both garage floors. Keep in mind that, for this article, we will not be talking about compartment mats, but rather how entire garage floor coverings compare to epoxy paint. Since the smaller garage floor mats are typically not sold in packages intended to cover whole garage floors, it wouldn’t make much sense to compare them to epoxy paint.

A Garage Floor Mat Is Easier To Install Than Epoxy Garage Floor Paint

That is pretty much a “duh!” factor. A garage floor mat only requires the cutting and the placing, while epoxy paint takes not only hours to install, but also in between steps it takes hours to dry. Before you begin installing it is also a much bigger hassle because you need to prepare by cleaning your garage to be immaculate. But, installing a mat on above dust, dirt, or grime works just the same. If you really need a “quick fix,” then you should really consider garage floor mats.

Garage Floor Mats Are Most Expensive Than Epoxy Garage Floor Coating

A garage floor mat, generally speaking, is likely to cost around $200, which is around three times how much epoxy garage floor coating costs. This difference in pricing really makes sense if you think about what you’re buying, and not just the end product. A garage floor covering gives you a pre-assembled solution while epoxy garage floor paint requires some assembly. If you have to pay someone to install your epoxy garage floor coating, though, the price will change radically since it takes hours to install, so be sure to figure that in as well if you don’t plan to install your own coating. If paying someone to install it, epoxy will almost always cost more in comparison to a garage floor mat.

Garage Floor Mats Are Less Durable Than Epoxy Garage Floor Paint

When it comes to durability and longevity, epoxy definitely has the advantage, but it’s also a bit of a game changer. When you apply an epoxy garage floor coating, you are changing the nature of your garage flooring. Using a garage floor mat just covers it. Although it’s far less likely, it is feasible for either paint or mats to become damaged or stained, and if that does happen, it’s far more difficult to repair an entire paint job than swapping out a mat. However, if you have to swap your mat out, you’re out another $200. So I suppose you have to ask yourself: just how rough will I be on this new garage flooring?

And The Winner Is…

Of course, all of the garage flooring types are different, and there is still no single best one to choose. But these two, the epoxy garage floor paint and garage floor mats are very available and popular and long lasting. But, it is up to you, the customer, to decide what the best garage flooring is for you. And if you are lucky and money is of no concern for you, consider using both, epoxy floor coating and a garage floor covering on top.

Check out my garage floor site for more garage floor mat information.

Leave a Comment